Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. I receive a small commission at no cost to you when you make a purchase using my link.
Clean beauty products are receiving a lot more love… and this is a trend you might want to get in on ASAP.
Conventional eyeliner pencils are formulated with a ton of toxic ingredients (yes, toxic) that you probably don’t want to be near – let alone, to be applying them right onto your lash line!
Why buy any ol’ eyeliner that’s packed with harmful ingredients, when there are plenty of safer options out there?
Ingredients to Look for in Natural Eyeliner Pencils
The best natural eyeliner pencils are formulated with ingredients that possess natural healing properties usually sourced from fruits and herbs, or nourishing plant oils.
Here are some ingredients you WANT to see in your natural eyeliner pencil:
Jojoba Oil - Jojoba oil is a humectant, which means it helps our skin lock in the moisture! It also has hydrating, antioxidant, and antibacterial properties to support our skin health. Not to mention, it’s rich in vitamin E!
Shea Butter - Shea butter is ultra-nourishing! It deeply moisturizes our skin while supplying it with a healthy dose of essential nutrients to provide anti-aging and anti-inflammatory benefits.
Marula Oil - Marula oil delivers ultra-hydrating and soothing benefits to our skin. Rich in antioxidants, it keeps the skin nourished while providing anti-aging benefits. Its lightweight, non-greasy texture is an added bonus!
Coconut Oil - Coconut oil has antibacterial properties – it can effectively hydrate the skin while reducing inflammation.
Ingredients to Avoid
Here are some of the toxic ingredients you should avoid at all costs!
Parabens - Parabens are linked to a number of serious health risks! They can interfere with hormone activity, and cause developmental or reproductive toxicity.
Carbon Black - Carbon black is a dark black powder used to add pigment into cosmetics. It’s linked to cancer and organ toxicity.
Formaldehyde and Formaldehyde-Releasing Preservatives (FRPs) - This known human carcinogen can be absorbed through the skin! It’s linked to cancer and can also cause allergic skin reactions.
Butylated Hydroxyanisole (BHA) and Butylated Hydroxytoluene (BHT) - Long-term exposure to these chemicals can cause serious negative health effects, such as endocrine disruption, developmental and reproductive toxicity, organ system toxicity, and cancer.
Looking for the best natural eyeliner pencil to define your eyes? Here are our top picks!
The 9 Best Natural Eyeliner Pencils
You can expect bold color payoff from Alima Pure’s Natural Definition Eye Pencil. It’s highly pigmented and delivers long-lasting performance.
Formulated with Chamomile Flower Extract and other nourishing oils, such as Jojoba Oil and Mango Seed Oil, this natural eyeliner pencil delivers soothing and moisturizing benefits to the delicate eye area.
Pros
- Rich formula glides on smoothly.
- Beautiful selection of colors to complement your eye color.
- Formulated with moisturizing extracts to soothe and nourish the eye area.
Cons
- It tends to smudge during the day.
Where to Shop
Ilia’s Pure Eyeliner comes with twist up application and a built-in sharpener, which can definitely make your life a lot easier.
This eyeliner pencil is jam-packed with healing oils and soothing ingredients, such as Vitamin E, Sesame, and Shea Butter to nourish the eye area.
The rich, creamy texture is buildable and blendable – which means you don’t need expert level skills to achieve the perfect smoky eye!
Pros
- Built-in sharpener with twist up application.
- Buildable and blendable formula for a smoky eye effect.
- Ultra-nourishing ingredients to soothe the eye area.
Cons
- It doesn’t provide long-lasting performance.
- It isn’t highly pigmented.
Where to Shop
Looking for a highly pigmented natural eyeliner pencil? W3LL PEOPLE’s Hypnotist Eyepencil is your best bet! The rich texture glides on incredibly well to give you a precise line.
Formulated with ultra-nourishing ingredients like Jojoba Oil, you can easily blend out this moisturizing formula over the lid to achieve a gorgeous smoky eye.
Pros
- Contains Jojoba Oil
- Formula glides on smoothly
- Rich pigmentation
Cons
- It tends to smudge.
Where to Shop
Formulated with Coconut Oil and Carnauba Wax, Kjaer Weis’ Eye Pencil has a soft, butter-smooth texture that glides on like a dream! You can even use an angle brush to smudge this product into your lash line for a softer look.
Pros
- Creamy texture glides on smoothly.
- Bold color payoff.
- Fantastic color selection.
Cons
- Tip gets rounded easily due to its soft texture (need to sharpen it more often).
- Price point is on the higher end.
Where to Shop
A huge fan of the smoky eye look? Vapour’s Eye Definer is designed with a smudge tip on one end, which makes it super easy for you to achieve the perfect smoky eye.
Its rich formula works wonders for soothing and protecting the delicate eye area, formulated with Jojoba Oil, Shea Butter, and Marula Oil – which is rich in antioxidants!
Pros
- Formulated with ultra-nourishing ingredients.
- Designed with smudge tip on one end.
Cons
- The color payoff is faint.
- Don’t provide long-lasting performance.
- Relatively small size for the price you pay.
Where to Shop
Looking for a waterproof natural eyeliner pencil? Jillian Dempsey’s Eyeliner is waterproof and cruelty-free. Formulated with ultra-hydrating ingredients, such as Organic Jojoba Oil, Organic Shea Butter, and Marula Oil… you can expect this eyeliner to glide on smoothly over the lash line to achieve perfectly defined eyes.
Pros
- Built-in smudger for achieving smoky eye effect.
- Glides on smoothly.
- Cruelty-free.
Cons
- It’s not waterproof.
- Tends to smudge during the day.
Where to Shop
Formulated with Jojoba Oil, Lily Lolo’s Eye Pencil delivers a ton of moisture to the delicate eye area. But if you’re looking for a wide color selection – keep in mind that this eye pencil is only available in two shades. The good news is, the price point is on the lower end compared to similar products on the market!
Pros
- Formula glides on smoothly
- Highly pigmented.
- Great for precision, whether you want to draw a thick or thin line.
- Price point is on the lower end.
Cons
- Doesn’t last long.
- Tends to smudge during the day.
- Only 2 color options available.
Where to Shop
I love the simple but sleek design of this eye pencil! The gentle formula of Ere Perez’s Jojoba Eye Pencil is suitable for sensitive eyes. Formulated with Jojoba Oil, this ultra-hydrating formula provides soothing benefits to the eye area, along with the promise of stimulating lash growth.
Pros
- Creamy formula glides on smoothly.
- Blends well.
- Plenty of beautiful shades to choose from.
- Formulated with jojoba oil, which can help stimulate lash growth.
Cons
- Tends to smudge during the day.
Where to Shop
Inika’s Certified Organic Eye Pencil is vegan and cruelty-free! It has a soft, creamy texture that glides on incredibly well during application. The organic formula is gentle enough to be used on sensitive eyes.
Pros
- Vegan and cruelty-free.
- Certified organic.
- Formula is suitable for sensitive eyes.
Cons
- It tends to smudge and doesn’t last long.
- A ton of mixed reviews, with some saying the texture is soft and some saying it’s not soft at all.
Where to Shop
Conclusion
Leading a happier, healthier life begins with being more health-conscious with our everyday decisions. And you definitely don’t want to apply an eyeliner that’s full of toxic chemicals onto the rim of your eye – ick!
We hope this guide was helpful for helping you choose the best natural eyeliner pencil. We always love hearing from you!
Let us know in the comments down below about your own experience with natural eyeliner pencils or feel free to leave behind any thoughts or questions you might have for us.
Dear ! What is the best choice if I would like to start my “cleanbeuty” makeuplife 🙂 … ?
I use black Eyepencil into my waterline and blend to my lashline ! Can U help me ?
Hi there Monka, the best way to start with clean makeup is to slowly replace your conventional makeup as you use it up, focusing on the products you use daily. We have lots of articles with product recommendations – you can see them here. There are a couple of articles on the site that may be useful to you – how to make the switch to organic products and how to green your beauty routine.
I hope that helps! Let me know if you have any other questions!