Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. I receive a small commission at no cost to you when you make a purchase using my link.
I remember being in high school with an incredibly limited but efficient makeup collection. It was picture day my senior year and I had completely forgotten about it. All I had on hand was a lipstick at the bottom of my bookbag and some mascara. The warm-toned nude lipstick was all I had to use for a full face on picture day so it quickly tripled as a lip liner, bronzer, and cream eyeshadow. Besides being impressed by my impromptu creativity, I became obsessed with the idea of using cream pigments on my eyelids.
Fortunately, my makeup collection has upgraded and you don’t have to use a sketchy lipstick to create a glossy glam eye look. With the best organic cream eyeshadows 2020, you can create a seamless bronze blend, dramatic smokey eyes, or a cool-toned fall look in a few easy swipes.
How to Use Organic Cream Eyeshadows
Your tool of choice will depend on how precise you want to place a cream eyeshadow. Sharp clean lines can be applied with a dense lining pencil while highlights to the brow bone or deepening the eye-socket can be blended with your finger or a loose blending eyeshadow brush.
Cream eyeshadows pair beautifully with powder shadows, so don’t feel limited. They will blend nicely and give dimension to the eyes. Cream shadows also make a powerful monochromatic look. Each shadow on this look can be played up to make a statement or make the perfect finishing touch to a standard day look.
Go For The Glow
It’s pretty easy to incorporate organic cream eyeshadows into your makeup look, but for the biggest impact, use cream shadows with an all cream makeup look. From cream foundation, a multistick for blush or bronzer, to a luscious lip balm, an entire cream-based makeup look makes for seamless blending and youthful beauty.
7 Best Organic Cream Eyeshadows of 2020
This buildable and blendable cream pigment makes for a luscious cream eyeshadow, radiant flush of blush, or semi-matte lip color. Offered in 9 versatile shades, Rituel de Fille offers glossy or matte, sparkles or not, and has all the important colors covered--from rosy pinks, stand out red, to dusty sand, and deep mauves. The smooth texture and luxury finish is a result of the Jojoba oil that carries the pigment. It’s hydrating for your skin and makes for gentle and easy application and blending.
Pros
- Beautiful rose scent
- Applies naturally and can be built up
- Easy to blend
- Moisturizing
- Highly pigmented
- Can be used on the lips and cheeks
- Universally flattering colors
Cons
- Some people find they have to reapply often
Where to Shop
Made with cocoa butter, this creamy packed pigment creates a dewy, youthful finish on the eyelids. Build your shadow with a variety of the Jillian Dempsey Lid Tints for the ultimate wet look that will have you runway ready. The natural and organic ingredients make this cream shadow gentle enough for all skin types. Coverage is glossy, buildable, and brightens eyes for a captivating finish.
Pros
- Smells great
- Super light and natural
- Sheer, subtle colors
- Easy and quick to apply
Cons
- May crease
Where to Shop
These boldly pigmented cream potions will make your lids glow and gleam. The Celestial Sphere Eye Soots are mistake-proof and blend beautifully over powder eyeshadow or another cream shadows for a pop of glimmer and glamor. I didn’t tell you--but they also make for a divine cream highlighter and lip topper. Choose from 4 vibrant and iridescent shades.
Pros
- Gorgeous and unique colors
- Applies beautifully
- Perfect amount of sparkle
- Formulation is smooth
- Highly pigmented
- Creamy, but with a powdery finish
- Easy to blend
Cons
- May smudge or crease without a lid primer
Where to Shop
The RMS Beauty Eye Polish may be one of the creamiest on the list. These soft and sheer cream eyeshadows are formulated with organic coconut oil for a smooth and hydrating application. Cocoa seed butter and rosemary extract combine to reduce puffiness or sensitivity on the eyelids. The finish of each shade is delicate, sheer, but buildable to medium opacity. There are 8 lovely earth tones to choose from. The collection is perfect for a soft day glam on the go.
Pros
- Quick and easy to apply
- Perfect for dryer eyelids
- Right amount of subtle shimmer
- Great for everyday wear
- Layers well
- Super creamy
Cons
- Can crease
Where to Shop
Contrary to other best organic cream eyeshadows in 2020, The Eyes Have It by The Organic Skin Co. is anything but sheer or subtle. Stand out with these hyper-pigmented, long-wearing cream shadows. Choose from 9 universally flattering shimmer shades, each as smooth and bold as the other. Botanical oils including calendula and pomegranate extracts make this rich formula ultra-soothing and brightening.
Pros
- Great colors
- Beautiful texture
- Cream dries to a powder finish
- Very pigmented and buildable
- Highlight and dark purple look amazing with blue eyes
Cons
- The pod sometimes spins in the casing
Where to Shop
Eyes, cheeks, lips...oh my! The HAN Multistick is the perfect creamy pop of color any time, anywhere. Suitable for all skin types, the Han multi-stick is formulated with acai oil, organic shea butter, and argan oil for a creamy application, dewy finish, and antioxidant skincare benefits. Han believes in their plant and mineral-based pigments as a safer alternative to conventional eyeshadow, blush, or balms. Trade the quality of ingredients but never sacrifice vibrancy or color. Apply the creamy multistick by warming by rubbing it with your fingertips and dabbing it onto your face. Choose from 4 natural colors including dusty rose, toasted nutmeg, nude pink, and burgundy rose.
Pros
- Looks natural on the skin
- Put the color on your lips, cheeks, and lids for a put-together look
- Lasts all day
- Soft, dewy color
- Doesn't streak
- Great for travel or touch-ups
Cons
- Some people find it not pigmented enough
Where to Shop
The Kjaer Weis Cream Eye Shadow is a mouse-like pigment with deep and dense colors meant to be pressed on or smudged out. Offered in four velvety shades, this cream eye shadow is the most dive-centric on our list of best organic cream eyeshadows of 2020. Smokey, shimmery, bold, and long-lasting these creamy eye shadows will give depth to a smokey eye (shade: Enticing) or brighten the eyes (shad: Alluring). Whichever shade you choose (get em all!), they’re guaranteed to make an impact.
Pros
- Goes on well with just a finger
- Glides on smoothly and evenly
- Great for sensitive skin
- Cruelty-free
- Refillable container
Cons
- May crease on oily lids but easy to blend back out
Where to Shop
Conclusion
Tap it on lightly or pack on the dreamy drama. You can’t go wrong with my favorite list of best organic cream eyeshadows of 2020.
Thanks for reading!
Leave a Reply