Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. I receive a small commission at no cost to you when you make a purchase using my link.
Well-shaped eyebrows can make or break a look. But they’re so much more than a final touch to your glam eye makeup. Brows are an easy way to add shape and dimension to your face. Even if you’re rockin the “no makeup, makeup” look, beautifully sculpted brows offer a clean, natural, and youthful look and will have you looking put together in minutes.
To get your brows precisely how you want them--bushy and bright-eye or arched to the sky, here are the 7 best organic eyebrow pencils that are absolute must-haves. Clean ingredients, top-rated, and effective, you can’t go wrong with these fan faves.
The 7 Best Organic Eyebrow Pencils of 2020
Double-sided and retractable, PYT defining brow pencil offers everything you need for a natural look. The unique shades offered to match any natural hair color and blend seamlessly with brow hairs. The retractable tip is wide and angled making application fool-proof and easy for on the go.
Pros
- Ideal for filling natural brows
- Thick applicator
- Smooth application
- Includes spoolie for taming
Cons
- May smudge
- Not precise due to wide applicator
- Not ideal for oily skin
Where to Shop
Alima Pure Natural Definition Brow Pencil is the familiar product we’re all used to but with luxury finesse. Offered in a limited range of natural shades, the pigment is subtle, soft, and glides on effortlessly. Made with natural fruit and seed oils, the Alima Pure Brow Pencil is creamy and soft making lines natural and blended and never harsh for realistic and clean hair-like application.
Pros
- Smooth application
- Thin pencil-tip for precision
- Natural-looking
- Ideal for filling
Cons
- Limited shade options
- May sharpen unevenly
- Luxury priced
Where to Shop
Comb, glide, fill, and define brows with Ere Perez’s uniquely creamy almond eyebrow pencil. This neutral tone was selected as a universal shade to match perfectly with almost any hair color and skin tone. The pigment is easily controlled by how hard you apply the product. With a firm press, apply smooth, natural-looking hairs on the inner brow and for shaping. Then, with a lighter touch, fill in the brow for seamless blending. And finally, perfecting the look with a run-through with the spoolie.
Pros
- Pigmented
- Precise point applicator
- Includes spoolie for taming and shaping
- Sharpens evenly
Cons
- Only one universal shade offered (Almond Brown)
- Luxury pricing
- Requires regular sharpening
Where to Shop
Vapour brings us a creamy and luxurious brow definer pencil formulated with organic shea butter, nourishing jojoba along with sunflower oils making this brow pencil suitable for even the most sensitive skin types. Natural shades offer a clean, full look to spruce up bare brows. The essential fatty acids found in the formula nourish brow hairs for strength and structure and make application slide right on..
Pros
- Creamy application
- Includes Spoolie
- Narrow precision point tip
- Formulated with organic butter and oils for sensitive skin
Cons
- Not long-lasting
- Limited shade range (light & dark brown)
- Not as effective on oily skin
- Luxury Priced
Where to Shop
Kimiko offers a top-rated Automatique twist-up brow pencil designed to make your brown look like you’ve hired a professional makeup artist to sculpt your brows each time. The super-fine tip of the pencil is for precision and the formula makes it nearly unbreakable and able to stand up to shaky hands. The dry formula makes it long-lasting and able to outlast heat and humidity. A covered spoolie brush is attached for beautiful feathering.
Pros
- Long-lasting formula
- Includes spoolie
- Designed for fool-proof application
- Twist-up pencil
- Comes in 3 universal shades
Cons
- It is a bit pricey
Where to Shop
Tired of having to sharpen and shape your brow pencil? Ecobrow Defining Crayon is sturdy like a pencil without the hassle. Maintaining its unique slanted tip, this non-waxy formula is built for pigment and durability. Its design is great for filling brows as each swipe replicates the natural swoop of healthy, thick, eyebrow strands and you never have to worry about the tip becoming dull.
Pros
- Uniquely angled tip for elegant hair-like application and smooth filling
- Retractable pencil
- Includes high-quality spoolie brush
- Comes in 6 shades
- Pigmented to perfection
- Smear-proof
Cons
- Some users mention application can be too dry
Where to Shop
Fill, finesse, and nourish brows all in one with the Plume Nourish & Define Brow Pencil. Elevate, elongate, and treat your brows to a pencil that does more than just sculpt and fill. Strengthen the hairs you currently have for a fuller tomorrow. Vitamin-rich organic castor oil and shea butter nurture hair follicles while adding an all-day defined look.
Pros
- Uniquely angled tip for elegant hair-like application and smooth filling
- Retractable pencil
- Includes high-quality spoolie brush
- Formulate to help natural brow hairs grow
- Offered in 6 shades
Cons
- Application tip is super-fine require a little extra effort to apply
Where to Shop
Tips to Using a Brow Pencil
So many people focus on getting the brows to match, remember--they’re sisters, not twins. In general, there are three essential ways to use a brow pencil. The first step is using a brown brush, comb, or spoolie. This is going to tame brow hairs so that you can create your desired shape and definition. This is also the perfect time to trim or pluck flyaways so the final result will be clean and precise.
The second step is to outline, underline, or shape the brow. These are usually longer strokes to create the shape you want before filling it in. This is also where you’ll determine how long or short you want the brow “tail” to be and where you want the arch placed.
Finally, using small, hair-like strokes flick the brow pencil up and out in the direction of your natural brow hairs to give a full, natural appearance. The drawn on hairs can be slightly longer and thicker than your natural brows as long as the shade match is within a reasonable range. For a finishing touch, go back in with your spoolie (brow brush) to buff out and harsh lines or edges. Finish with a natural eyeliner pencil for a sultry look made with chemical-free products.
Conclusion
I hope you enjoyed this roundup of the best organic eyebrow pencils. Let us know how you like these products, or if there are any other products you think should be added to the list!
Hi andrea , Thanks for this amazing information.l haven’t heard about the almond eyebrow pencil before. Am looking forward for more recommendations