10 Best Organic Eye Creams of 2019

We know—quite the controversial topic recently, eye creams are. Simply asked: Are eye creams really that necessary as part of a beauty regimen?

If you want to take preventative measures and combat signs of aging (think fine lines, wrinkles, and dark spots), yes, you should be using an eye cream.

That’s to say, if you can afford an eye cream—and there are inexpensive options!—and you want to take care of your skin, we suggest getting yourself one of these eye creams listed below.

Why? Eye creams are expensive, after all!

We know, but hear us out: Since the skin surrounding the eyes is much more fragile than other parts of your face, a specially formulated moisturizer is required. The eyes are typically the first spots to show aging, so products that are more highly concentrated are needed to retain the skin’s moisture and maintain elasticity.

Now, what are some organic, natural options to choose from? See our list below for our 10 favorite eye creams!

To be sure you’re getting the highest quality eye cream that doesn’t irritate your skin, make sure to look for these ingredients. These days, these ingredients are all the rage:

• Organic oils: Containing fatty acids to seep your skin with moisture and reduce puffiness, organic oils—such as rosehip, jojoba, and almond—work wonders to cast off dryness.
• Aloe vera: A deeply hydrating ingredient, aloe vera is also known to bring life back to dead skin cells.
• Hyaluronic acid: We can’t rave about hyaluronic acid enough! In its plant-based form, this power ingredient boasts a number of advantages with usage—one of those being ultra-hydrated skin.
• Essential oils: The safer alternative to fragrances. Eye creams formulated with essential oils give off extremely relaxing, therapeutic vibes.

​Ingredients to Avoid in an Eye Cream

Now you know what to look for in eye creams … what about ingredients to avoid? Be sure to check the ingredients list for each product you buy to ensure you’re getting something that won’t be harmful. These are the ingredients you don’t want to have contact with:

• Parabens: Widely used in conventional eye creams for their preserving qualities, these guys are actually toxic and have been studied to be a cause of breast cancer.
• Phthalates: Not actually noted on the ingredient label, but these are often disguised as “fragrance” or “parfum.” Watch out for these as they are known to be disruptive to hormones.
• Synthetic colors: Sure, these make your conventional eye creams pretty to look at—but you don’t really want coal tar on your skin, do you? Typically, synthetic colors are created from a base of carcinogenic coal tar.
• Dimethicone: Widely used for its skin conditioning abilities, dimethicone causes both skin and eye irritation, which is especially problematic for users of eye creams.

To say farewell to dark circles, the Goldfaden M.D Bright Eyes Dark Circle Radiance Complex is all you need. Hyaluronic acid makes the skin under your eyes plump while soy peptides decrease overall puffiness.

Upon application, you’ll notice a lovely cool feeling as the product begins sinking into your skin. For us, we saw changes within only a matter of days. This eye cream is fast-acting and lightweight. It’ll be easy to fall in love with this one!

Bring brightness into your undereyes with the Sahajan Radiance Eye Cream. Its Ayurvedic formula—containing mango seed butter, neem, and triphala—soothes and protects the most delicate part of your face. It absorbs into the skin quickly and replenishes where hydration is lacking.

This eye cream has a rich texture, but it doesn’t sit heavily on the skin. Instead, it absorbs in a matter of minutes, leaving only a barrier of moisture that keeps you coming back for more.

Need a little pick-me-up in the mornings to fight those sleepy eyes? The 100% Pure Coffee Bean Caffeine Eye Cream is your answer. Formulated with green coffee beans and rosehip oil to provide your skin with antioxidants, this eye cream doubles as anti-aging.

We love how hydrating this eye cream feels on the skin, and we saw improvements to our skin in the way of reduction of fine lines, puffiness, and dark circles. The scent has notes of vanilla, rosemary, and thyme.

A decadent eye cream that goes a long way, the Goop Perfecting Eye Cream is worth all the rage. When applied to the under eyes, this eye cream feels as luxurious as you would hope for with its price tag. With powerful plant extracts (like sweet iris, honeysuckle, and poet’s daffodil) and aloe vera juice, this product delivers on all its promises.

This eye cream also contains highly effective and hydrating peptides, which lock in moisture and tightens the skin. If you’re sensitive to scents, too, this would be a great eye cream for you, as there isn’t a discernible scent.

We’re in love with the Odacité Ultra Effective Eye Cream, stunned by its impactful formulation of aloe vera juice, hyaluronic acid, and evening primrose oil. This powerhouse of ingredients come together with their youth-giving properties, allowing those dark circles and fine lines to slip away.

If you’re skeptical about the effectiveness of eye creams, we encourage you to give this one the benefit of the doubt. You only need a tiny bit for each application—and, almost immediately, we’re certain you’ll notice results.

We hadn’t heard of echium seed extract before trying out the Pai Skincare Echium and Argan Gentle Eye Cream, but now we’re sold. Rich in omegas three and six, this ingredient will bring the moisture back into your under eyes, while plumping the skin and restoring its youthfulness.

This eye cream is non-irritating and packed with antioxidants, making it a great selection for those with very sensitive skin. It exceeded our expectations in decreasing the appearance of fine lines in a gentle manner.

The Dr. Alkaitis Organic Eye Creme is light and delicate for the sensitive area surrounding the eyes. With aloe vera gel as the base, the formula quickly seeps into the skin, leaving nothing of an unpleasant residue. This cream contains Dr. Alkaitis’s Eye Rejuvenation and Support Complex, complete with cold-pressed jojoba oil, rosehip seed and borage oils, and shea butter.

Upon application, this eye cream immediately calms the skin. Although it is lightweight, we’ve noticed the telltale signs of a superb eye cream: reduction in fine lines, dark circles, and puffiness.

A formula containing a host of plant and seed extracts, the Tata Harper Restorative Eye Creme is a powerful anti-aging product that rejuvenates the under eyes. With 66% of its ingredients cultivated from organic farming and 100% of natural origin, there’s no way to feel bad about letting this product soak into your skin.

This eye cream has a light lemon and herbal scent that some may not enjoy, but we were fond of it. Carrot seed oil, in particular, protects your delicate skin, while date palm extract reduces fine lines, wrinkles, and other signs of aging.

For all eye issues related to puffiness and stubborn dark circles, we recommend the Kahina Giving Beauty Eye Cream. Not only were we amazed with how quickly results came about, but we were genuinely impressed with the peptide-rich formula that also contains hydrating hyaluronic acid.

The texture of this eye cream is gel-like and light. When applied to the skin, it is instantly soothing and brightening. After weeks of using this product, we noticed a healthier-looking eye area that glowed.

A rich, hydrating eye cream containing high quality ingredients sourced from a personal garden in Austria? The Susanne Kaufmann Skincare Line T: Eye Cream is all of those things and more. Rosehip oil, hyaluronic acid, and broccoli seed oil pair together to reverse all signs of aging while dramatically minimizing skin irritation.

This is a beautiful eye cream that not only replenishes, but strengthens, the general eye area. Active plant botanicals are combined to form a brightening, calming product. Since this cream is quite rich, we recommend using it only for evenings and possibly as an eye mask.

Eye creams are the unsung heroes of all things skincare. When using the right one, they boast tremendous benefits: They can make the area surrounding your eyes appear more youthful; help diminish dark circles, fine lines, and wrinkles; and soothe the area to reduce puffiness.

Although you may doubt the power of an eye cream, we recommend giving them a try before you shrug them off altogether. From testing out and continually using these ones ourselves, we were very impressed with how effective they proved to be. You may be surprised yourself!

What’s your take on eye creams? Have you been using one? Or are you new to the game? Let us know in the comments section! It’s always wonderful hearing from you all. And, if you have any questions or comments, feel free to reach out to us as well. 

Thanks for joining us for this article!